Sign in

Homebuyers’ body FPCE seeks national real estate appellate tribunal, binding sale agreements and statutory exit route

FPCE has proposed establishing a National Appellate Tribunal for Real Estate (NATRE) in Delhi, on the lines of the NCLT and NGT and binding sale agreements

Updated on: Nov 16, 2026, 09:01:12 IST
Share
Share via
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
Copy link
  • copy link

The Forum for People's Collective Efforts (FPCE), a national homebuyers' body, has proposed a series of reforms to strengthen consumer protection in the real estate sector. Key recommendations include setting up a National Appellate Tribunal for Real Estate (NATRE) in Delhi, modelled on the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and National Green Tribunal (NGT), to replace state-level appellate tribunals; making Agreements for Sale legally binding under RERA; and introducing a statutory exit mechanism for homebuyers.

Homebuyers' body FPCE has proposed automatic compensation for homebuyers in cases of project delays or deficiencies, without requiring individual allottees to file complaints or undergo lengthy legal proceedings. (Picture for representational purposes only) (Pexels)
Homebuyers' body FPCE has proposed automatic compensation for homebuyers in cases of project delays or deficiencies, without requiring individual allottees to file complaints or undergo lengthy legal proceedings. (Picture for representational purposes only) (Pexels)

FPCE has also proposed automatic compensation for homebuyers in cases of project delays or deficiencies, without requiring individual allottees to file complaints or undergo lengthy legal proceedings.

Making a case for the exit provision, FPCE said, ‘A developer in distress may approach the National Company Law Tribunal; a family in distress has nowhere to go.

The proposals were submitted to officials of the Cabinet Secretariat during a meeting on November 12, following a response from Cabinet Secretary to the organisation’s earlier letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi seeking reforms to the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016.

An FPCE delegation comprising its president Abhay Upadhyay and members Ratul Mazumder and Jai Pal Raheja presented the suggestions, which also include making real estate regulatory authorities accountable through periodic audits and ensuring automatic compensation to allottees in cases of project delays or deficiencies.

FPCE seeks National Appellate Tribunal for real estate

FPCE has proposed establishing a National Appellate Tribunal for Real Estate (NATRE) in Delhi, on the lines of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and National Green Tribunal (NGT), replacing the existing state-level appellate tribunals. Appeals against NATRE's decisions would lie directly with the Supreme Court.

The homebuyers’ organisation said differences in the interpretation and implementation of RERA across states have resulted in inconsistent protection for homebuyers. It also flagged vacancies and inadequate staffing in several state appellate tribunals, with some unable to function effectively due to a lack of quorum.

“The same provision of a central Act is today read differently from state to state, so that a homebuyer’s rights depend on where he happened to buy. A single appellate forum would build one body of RERA law for the whole country, as the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal and the National Green Tribunal have done in their fields,” FPCE said in a statement on November 14.

The proposed NATRE would hear appeals against orders passed by both real estate regulatory authorities and adjudicating officers. FPCE has also suggested virtual benches based on caseload so that homebuyers would not have to travel to Delhi to pursue appeals.

It has proposed that the tribunal's chairperson and members be appointed by the Central Government on the recommendation of a judicially led selection committee.

Agreement for Sale should be made legally binding

FPCE has sought amendments to Section 13(2) of RERA to include the Agreement for Sale in a schedule to the Act, making its provisions legally binding.

Under the existing framework, state governments prescribe the format of the agreement through rules. FPCE said this allows developers to introduce clauses that could dilute the protections intended under RERA.

“Builders continue to insert clauses that defeat the Act, and the agreements carrying them are uploaded on the Authorities’ own websites without scrutiny,” the organisation said.

Making the agreement part of the central legislation, it argued, would establish uniform standards and prevent contractual provisions from undermining statutory homebuyer rights.

Statutory exit mechanism proposed for homebuyers

Another key recommendation is the introduction of a statutory exit mechanism for homebuyers who wish to cancel their bookings for personal or financial reasons.

FPCE has proposed that buyers cancelling within one year of booking should receive a full refund within one month. For cancellations after the first year, it has suggested a refund of the entire amount paid, along with interest at the State Bank of India savings account rate.

The organisation said Section 18 of RERA primarily addresses situations involving developer defaults but does not adequately provide an exit route for homebuyers facing personal circumstances such as job losses or the death of an earning family member.

“A buyer who must withdraw for reasons of his own, the loss of employment, the death of an earning member, has no exit, and forfeits whatever the builder chooses to keep; in one case brought to FPCE, seventy-five per cent of the amount paid was retained as cancellation charges,” it said.

Drawing a comparison with insolvency proceedings available to developers, FPCE said: “A developer in distress may approach the National Company Law Tribunal; a family in distress has nowhere to go.”

Regular audits of RERA authorities, automatic compensation sought

FPCE has also called for greater accountability among state real estate regulatory authorities through periodic audits, independent scrutiny of a sample of their orders and public disclosure of audit findings.

It has further proposed automatic compensation for allottees in cases involving project delays or deficiencies, without requiring individual homebuyers to file complaints or pursue lengthy legal proceedings.

The organisation said the effectiveness of RERA should be assessed not merely by the number of registered projects but by the extent to which the law protects homebuyers in practice.

Abhay Upadhyay, president of FPCE, said: “Homebuyers have experienced the real estate sector both before and after RERA. While project registration is an important step, the real measure of the law’s success is the protection homebuyers receive in practice. Over the past decade, we have repeatedly raised concerns at the forums available to us because that protection remains inadequate.”

Also Read: West Asia crisis: Homebuyers question 4-month RERA project timeline extension, seek equal relief

He added that the organisation hoped the government would consider the proposals to ensure that homebuyer protection received focused attention, backed by clear accountability and without competing responsibilities compromising that objective.

Also Read: Homebuyers’ body FPCE urges PM Modi to restructure RERA as homebuyer protection law

In the letter to the PM, the FPCE had earlier pointed out that the RERA law in its current form has failed in its objective. Diversion of funds, endless delays, one-sided agreements and unenforced orders continue to haunt homebuyers across the country, it had pointed out. The association had recommended re-enactment or Renaming of RERA as the 'Real Estate Homebuyer Protection Act'.

A week after a homebuyers' forum approached Prime Minister Narendra Modi with concerns over the implementation of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, and sought amendments to strengthen consumer protection, Cabinet Secretary T V Somanathan responded on November 2, saying the suggestions would be “looked into”. Subsequently, Cabinet Secretariat officials met a delegation from the forum on November 12 to discuss the proposed reforms, FPCE said in a statement on Nov 15.

  • Vandana Ramnani
    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    Vandana Ramnani

    Vandana Ramnani leads the real estate vertical at Hindustan Times Digital, bringing over two decades of journalism experience across real estate, education, human resources, and foreign affairs. She specialises in India’s real estate sector, covering residential and commercial markets in Delhi-NCR, Mumbai, and Bengaluru, with in-depth reporting on regulatory developments, urban policy, housing trends, and interviews with industry leaders. Her work has also appeared in the Hindustan Times newspaper and HT Estates. Earlier, Vandana played a key role in establishing the real estate vertical at Moneycontrol (NW18 Group), shaping its editorial direction and market coverage. She has also written extensively on international education for HT Education, tracking global study destinations, policy changes, and student mobility trends, earning the Singapore Education Award 2009 for Best Media Coverage (Print). Her reporting portfolio includes human resources and employment trends for HT ShineJobs and PowerJobs, as well as lifestyle and interior design features for HT Premium Homes. Vandana began her career with the Press Trust of India, gaining strong editorial and reporting expertise. She was also selected for a prestigious fellowship at Fondation Journalistes en Europe in Paris, where she wrote for EuroMag. One of her notable reporting assignments included covering Germany’s capital relocation from Bonn to Berlin. Outside of journalism, Vandana is a passionate traveller, constantly seeking out charming hideaways across India and the lesser-known, offbeat corners of Southeast Asia.Read More

Stay updated with the latest Real Estate News, property prices, housing trends and major projects. Explore market updates, investment insights and property developments across India.